The Witness in the Valley

An Album By

With a Voice

Review by

It takes some serious skills to be a good screamer and not ruin your voice live (or in the studio) within a short amount of time. Screamer and lead vocalist for With a Voice, Dylan Raftevold, channels the post-hardcore/ metalcore screaming really well. He reminds listeners of A Day to Remember’s Jeremy McKinnon and A Hope for Home’s Nathan Winchell, while the clean vocals can be matched to some of We Came As Romans’ better tracks.

With a Voice’s new album, The Witness In The Valley, is a mixed bag of the metalcore genre and pure, post-hardcore. Many songs have faster and darker breakdowns, while the interludes in the middle of songs (like “Phantom Pain”) border on the post-hardcore, non-metal feel. While it’s easily the best track here (even if it drags a bit), the album tends to feel a bit like a sampler platter of what the band’s been working on for a long time.

Other tracks like “The Hero I Had” may remind listeners of the hardcore we heard from fan favorites Chasing Victory, without the raw rock placement. Since forming in 2010, this is With a Voice’s first full-length, which is surprising for a band with a decent following and experience playing hundreds of shows with big names. The songs show the group’s age, and, unfortunately, it showcases only glimpses of what a band like this is capable of.

For fans of A Day To Remember (screams, breakdowns) , A Hope For Home (heavy aspect).


The Undertaking 2021

Quite The Undertaking

Frenzied. Chaotic. Punk. The Undertaking!, San Diego's newest wild bunch, is about to release their debut album, and, if their live show is a premonition of any kind, the world will be opening up to one heck of a party with them. Contributing writer Andrew Voigt talks to vocalist Austin Visser about the band's new album, the reality of their music, and how they've been able to embrace their creative freedom.


Full Feature
All Features