Appeals court finds that First Amendment lawsuit by Texas high school student forced to cheer for her rapist was not “frivolous”; 140,000 call on school to refuse to take money from the victim.

The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has overruled a decision by a lower court requiring a Texas cheerleader to pay $35,000 in legal fees after suing her school for forcing her to cheer for a basketball player who pled guilty to sexually assaulting her.

After the cheerleader was removed from the squad for refusing to cheer her attacker by name, her family brought a lawsuit against the school district.

The decision, issued Monday, reverses a ruling by a lower court which previously found the cheerleader’s suit “frivolous”, ordering the student to pay the school district $35,000 in legal expenses. The lower court will now be required to “recalculate” the amount owed.

The news comes after more than 140,000 people joined a popular campaign on calling on Silsbee High School to admit to mistreating the student, apologize for the actions against her, improve district policy for dealing with sexual assault, and refuse to take money from the girl and her family.

“The outpouring of support for this Texas cheerleader from well over a hundred thousand people is evidence that her story has touched many hearts,” said Senior Organizer Alex DiBranco. “The demonstration of support has meant a lot to this teenager and her family, and while this court decision represents a partial victory for them, members continue to tell the school district that it’s wrong to take a single penny from this student.”

Activists have raised money to cover the student’s legal fees and launched a protest campaign in which people mail pennies to the school.

Live signature totals from the campaign:

For more information on, please visit: is the world’s fastest-growing platform for social change — growing by more than 400,000 new members a month, and empowering millions of people to start, join, and win campaigns for social change in their community, city and country.


Atreyu- 2021

Atreyu's Baptism

At their core, Atreyu is a hard rock band with metal riffs and pop choruses. Now, after more than 20 years, the band has stepped boldly into their next chapter with a change in lineup and an album that proves the lifeblood of Atreyu is stronger than ever.


Photo by Ashley Osborn

Full Feature
Heaven's Metal: An Oral History of the Genesis of Christian Metal

Heaven's Metal

When rock emerged from blues and 'heavy metal' began to surface, faith-based metal acts also rose to start their own journeys. Initially shunned by both believers and non-believers, they were fighting for their spot at the table, ultimately building a legacy that would go on to change the genre forever. HM presents an oral history of the beginning of Christian metal music, featuring Guardian, Tourniquet, Holy Soldier, Whitecross, and, of course, Stryper.


Full Feature
Imperial Triumphant - 2021

Alphaville’s Metal Renaissance

With influences that span Miles Davis and Stravinsky to Geddy Lee and Les Claypool, jazz metal force Imperial Triumphant is the epitome of genre-bending. HM contributing writer Andrew Voigt spoke with the band about their unique style, the massive bass presence in their music, and the rise and fall of civilization.


Photo by Alex Krauss

Full Feature
All Features